Last week I got to raid Amanda’s sock drawer and take photos of her hand knit socks that still reside in her household. I took photos (sans lightbox, which I found was a mistake, but I was lazy and didn’t want to drag it over to her house) and she kindly wrote up a review of the yarns she has used. Due to some photo troubles a few of the sock yarns have been left out. For that I apologize.
In case you missed it, my reviews from this year can be found in the Oct 31st post, and last year’s reviews can be found here. Now, onto Amanda’s assessment of several sock yarns…
I’ve probably knit 30 pairs of socks by now, including those that have been gifted. I don’t believe in handwashing my socks and treating them delicately - they are on my feet all day after all. So, I generally opt for superwash fibers that I then throw in the washing machine (usually on cold or cold/warm) and will even put them in the dryer a bit on low temp to help speed the drying process before hanging them or laying them flat to dry (depending on where I have space). Here I’m sharing the wear of socks that live in our house and are subjected to these conditions. They’ve been knit over the course of several years. I prefer a tighter gauge so that I can’t feel the stitches on the soles of my feet. My husband on the other hand, doesn’t tend to have as tender a foot so I opt to knit his socks at a looser gauge to get them done faster. However, you can see this has had an impact on the longevity of some of his socks. Comparing our socks is a bit apples to oranges though considering he wears handknit socks nearly EVERYDAY and I actually will wear commercial socks which means mine aren’t on quite the same frequent rotation as his are.
We wear our socks in everyday shoes so I choose to knit fingering weight. The heaviest socks I’ve knit are the Socks That Rock medium weight which is a heavy finger weight to light dk/sport weight. For a sweater gauge I would probably use a US 3 although I knit these socks on a US 2.
Silja
8.5 sts/inch
Although not widely available I’ve found this yarn to be a great option if you’re looking for a wide range of solid colors. Check out
the selection at TheKnitter.com. Overall I’m very happy with the wear on these socks (some piling but this is what I would consider normal) and would use this yarn again although I wouldn’t say it was a favorite yarn to work with. It didn’t have a magnificent hand, but at the same time it didn’t have any drawbacks.
Brown Sheep Wildfoote Luxury Sock Yarn
Color SY-100 Rock ‘n Roll
75% Washable wool, 25% Nylon
7 sts/inch
This is another yarn that is available in several solids, barber pole styles (bi- and tri-color twists), and variegateds. Unfortunately, this yarn can be a bit splitty and notice that although the two socks are from two skeins that are the same color and dyelot they do not truly match. I started the socks on Swallow casein needles and found that the combination caused some headaches as the yarn stuck to the needles too much. The socks have worn well, some felting has occurred on the heels (where I used reinforcement thread as well) but nothing major.
Mist
100% Superwash Merino
Pattern: Weekend Knitting, Petticoat Socks by Veronik Avery
7 sts/inch
This yarn of fairly recent fame grabbed my attention when The Fold sold out of nearly 800 skeins in the first few hours they were open at The Maryland Sheep and Wool Festival a couple years ago. Sadly, my socks are already showing considerable wear after only a few wearings/washings (this is the youngest pair of the bunch here). Of course this is due in part to my care for them. On the inside of the ball band it does say: “Superwash yarn is machine washable. However, we recommend for a longer life turn inside out and handwash in warm water with mild detergent.”
I have not followed this suggestion. However, I’ve found most of the wear to coincide to my Dansko Mary Jane style clogs. Where the strap rubs against the foot I have a furry abraded bit, in addition to the allover halo the sock has developed. So, sure you can blame the shoe, however, I wear these same shoes with all my handknit socks and so far this is the only pair of socks to show this anomaly. Still the yarn is a joy to work with and I have and will continue to use it for nonsock knitting. Currently, on the needles are a few baby hats and they look great. I can get three of these hats out of one skein.
Lang Jawoll & Lang Jawoll Color
75% New Wool, 18% Nylon, 7% acrylic
830198 (green) 8.5 sts/inch
820089 (multi-color) 8 sts/inch
The green socks were knit in 2002 and were in heavy rotation when I first completed them. They sort of got forgotten when the sweater they matched perfectly (from J. Crew) shrank a little in the wash. They are worn inside out for a smoother fabric against the foot. No noticeable halo on these socks and only slight felting on my pressure points. The yarn shows great stitch definition and as a bonus comes with a spool of matching reinforcement thread in the center of the skein.
The multi-color ones sadly have not held up as well as my green pair. I think this is due mostly to the gauge difference. This yarn certainly benefits from a tighter gauge. But, this pair has also been worn far more than mine. I will be darning the balls of the feet before they are worn again.
Fortissima Colori Sock Color
Color 2412
75% Virgin wool, 25% Polyamide
8 sts/inch
What a fun yarn to work with - very much like Trekking. This yarn had a great soft hand. There has been some haloing, but again I feel this is due more to the gauge than the yarn itself and with as much regular wear as it is put through I think that the amount of age the sock shows is perfectly appropriate.
80% New Wool, 20% Polyamid
Meilenweit Fantasy Color 4710 (Rainbow) 8.5 sts/inch
(purple/mustard/brown/orange stripes) 8.5 sts/inch
Meilenweit Multiringel Color 5090 (Pinks/Yellow stripes) 10 sts/inch
Meilenweit Fantasy Color 4760 (Green/Blue/Orange) 9.5 sts/inch
Not only is this a reliable yarn I might even venture to say it’s my favorite, or tied for first place. I’ve knit it in several gauges and
found that it lasts regardless. The colors are bright and have lasted. There has been no haloing or piling to speak of. A few of the most heavily worn pairs have shown slight felting in the high wear areas, but nothing major. I’m still impressed with the lack of haloing and piling.
Regia
75% New Wool, 25% Polyamide
Regia Line Steps Color 5363 (Cream) 8.5 sts/inch (see here)
Regia Jacquard 5294 (Pastel) 8.5 sts/inch (see here)
(blues/greens) 8 sts/inch
(Blue w/ color bursts) 7.5 sts/inch
This is a reliable yarn. Every pair of socks I’ve knit from them (I can think of 8 off the top of my head) have worn well. The newer ones show little haloing, but nothing more. The ones shown here are the first pair of socks I knit for my now husband (Valentine’s 2002). Since they were his only handknit pair of socks for nearly a wear they have seen more washings than I can count. At least two wears per week for a few winters. Now, they aren’t as pretty due to some slight felting and piling. But, they haven’t lost any of their color. In fact, they still match the left over yarn - which is great since I need to darn the balls of the feet before their next wear.
The photo at the top of the post was my first pair of socks I ever knit. They’ve had lots of wear, and are probably my favorite. Even though the heel is knit in St St rather than a “heel” stitch of some sort it still looks good. Sure there is some slight felting, but it’s very minor and there is no halo to speak of, even at this relatively loose gauge.