Fiber Fool

Follow the feats and foibles of a fiber fanatic.

A Red Velvet Disaster

Filed under: In the Kitchen — Kristi at 8:27 am on Wednesday, May 24, 2006

This weekend I did a trial run of a red velvet cake. See, my friends sometimes have an odd sense of humor and you combine that with a love of themed parties and you end up with an evil party on 06-06-06. I thought a red velvet cake would be fun since it is red, but I had never made one before. I decided to use the chocolate one from Martha Stewart. It wasn’t hard until I came to the baking part.

As you can see, the cakes fell. And they fell hard. The center of them? Probably 1/4 inch thick if I’m lucky. There were many adjustments made so I do not know what the real cause of the fall was. Firstly, we had to use 7-in pans rather than the 8 that were called for as we only had one 8-in. That meant that not only were the layers a bit thicker but the baking time was questionable and that meant towards the end of the bake time I was opening and closing the oven every 5 minutes or so, not a great thing for the sturdiest of cakes. Secondly, this recipe did not have specific adjustments for altitude so I followed those set out by DH’s baking bible. But, this involved changing the amounts on many different ingredients - cutting back liquid (I split it between the water and the buttermilk), cutting back baking powder, increase oven temp by 25 degrees, etc. I also used Wilton’s paste food coloring rather than the bottles of liquid so your redness may vary.

We may give it another try this weekend, this time with the proper sized pans. I’m not sure what to do about the adjustments for altitude though. I don’t know if I will go ahead and give them a try one more time now that I’ll have a closer idea of the bake time, or if I’ll seek out another opinion on the adjustments for 5,000 ft.

It tasted really good anyway. The crumb was great, the chocolate was pretty subtle, but that allowed the cake to be really nice and red. The cream cheese frosting was light and fluffy and just the right amount of sweet. We served to some for fika this weekend (along with rugelach that DH made for the first time and had his own share of trouble with). They aren’t bakers (well, I’m not really either, which I was reminded off with this experience) but love baked things so they don’t mind things that don’t look as pretty as they should.

If you have a difinitive set of altitue adjustments for elevations around 5,000 ft I’m open to suggestions!

Well, I’m off now. I need to apologize in advance for not getting back to comments you all made yesterday. I will be out of the house the entire day as water aerobics is followed immediately by the baby shower which is followed by voice lessons (in fact, I may have to duck out of the shower early), etc. etc. I haven’t had such a crazy busy day in a loooong time. I’ll try get back to everyone this evening as well as make my usual blog rounds. I’ve been behind with the push to get the baby shower items completed and haven’t been commenting much, but I have been reading my entire blogroll. Oh, and Chris, I don’t know what it is but Blogger does not want me to comment on your blog, I’ve tried a few times in the past week without success… *sigh*

12 Comments »

287

Comment by Carole

May 24, 2006 @ 8:33 am

I love love love Red Velvet Cake! My grandma used to make it for me. yummm.

288

Comment by Lizzy B

May 24, 2006 @ 8:53 am

Ok, perfect or not, the cake looks scrumptious!

289

Comment by Hillary

May 24, 2006 @ 9:00 am

I’m at work not so I can’t check it myself but I live by the Cake Bible by Rose Levy Beranbaum and I’m pretty sure it has altitude adgustment information in there.

290

Comment by Stephanie

May 24, 2006 @ 9:23 am

I have a pretty unscientific way of adjusting for altitude, but it generally works. I live higher than you at about 7500 feet, but I generally add a couple of tablespoons of flour (for a recipe that calls for a couple of cups) and if the batter looks too dry, just a smidge of liquid (water usually). I find that I don’t have to adjust the soda/powder and generally the extra flour keeps it from raising too quickly (but I’ve been known to reduce the levening by a pinch in some cases - told you it was unscientific). I would say that the smaller pans (and therefore the thicker batter) plus a little more flour will fix all your problems. It looks yummy (oh, and I find I have the most trouble adjusting Martha Stewart recipes for some reason).

291

Comment by Chris

May 24, 2006 @ 9:33 am

Can you track down a different recipe?!

292

Comment by Rebekah

May 24, 2006 @ 10:44 am

Even though it was a disaster in some respects, it sure looks amazingly tasty. But then again, I’m really, really hungry right now.

293

Comment by Kimberly

May 24, 2006 @ 10:46 am

Honey, I’m going to gain 5 pounds just reading your blog!! That looks yummy eventhough it didn’t turn out the way it should have. Can I move in with you? ;o)

294

Comment by Erin

May 24, 2006 @ 1:01 pm

I am amazed you are trying out the recipe before the big party. I would have ended up serving cake with a dropped center due to poor planning.

And I have to ask…do you really watch Wildfire and Beautiful People? I thought my sister and I were the only adults who are loyal watchers of those guilty pleasure shows. We just love those BP’s and I love myself some Junior.

295

Comment by Julia

May 24, 2006 @ 1:45 pm

Why didn’t you just use the fallen cake for an Evil Party? What food says evil more than a fallen red velvet cake? (Especially if it tasted good!) My recommendation is to make another cake using exactly the same recipe, open the oven door every 5 minutes, and pray this one falls too. Maybe you can decorate it like a graveyard or something :-)

297

Comment by Jenni

May 24, 2006 @ 4:40 pm

Oh no! I have never tried to make red velvet cake before.

I agree with Julia. I fallen red velvet cake sounds like a great desert for a 666 party.

312

Comment by Elspeth

May 25, 2006 @ 7:01 pm

I love Red Velvet Cake! I need to try to make it sometime soon. Hope your next try works out!

Comment by tinka

June 18, 2008 @ 10:34 pm

Hey I came across this blog when looking for a red velvet cake for high altitude. Did you ever try it again? I made one from a different recipe but had the same problem. I don’t think the standard adjustments apply because of the vinegar and buttermilk in the recipe. At least the one I made had those ingredients. I’m going to try another one I read works at high altitude this weekend tho!

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>